Idaho Protest Against Law That Protects Parents That Deny Health Care To Children On Religious Grounds

Protesters carried 183 symbolic child-sized coffins to the Idaho Capitol steps on Monday, calling for Idaho to repeal its faith-healing exemption. That law allows parents to deny their children medical care without civil or criminal liability, even if the children die.
Protesters stacked 183 symbolic child-sized coffins on the Idaho Capitol steps on Monday, calling for Idaho to repeal its faith-healing exemption. That law allows parents to deny their children medical care without civil or criminal liability, even if the children die.

Idaho Statesman

“Protesters marched to the Idaho Capitol Monday bearing 183 child-sized, symbolic coffins, which they stacked on the Statehouse steps as they called for Idaho lawmakers to repeal the state’s faith-healing exemption. That law spares parents from criminal or civil liability if they deny their children medical care and the kids die.

The protesters said at least 183 Idaho infants, children and teens have died since the exemption laws were enacted by the Idaho Legislature in the 1970s.

“These coffins may be symbolic, but the children whose lives were cut short are not,” said Bruce Wingate, founder of Protect Our Kids. “This is not a religious issue. This is a child protection issue.”

betsy coffins 1

Lawmakers have considered re-examining the faith-healing exemption for several years now, but haven’t agreed to change anything in Idaho’s laws. A faith-healing sect based in Canyon County has strongly objected to repealing the exemption; members of the Followers of Christ told lawmakers at hearings last fall and spring that they believe using medicine is a sin, akin to “sorcery” and “witchcraft.”

Canyon County Sheriff Kieran Donahue told a Senate committee last March that in his county, he’d had three children die in the previous four months under the faith-healing exemption. “My hands are tied as a law enforcement officer,” he said. “It’s an embarrassment to our state.”

Idaho is one of just two states with faith-healing exemptions in four areas of its state law: Manslaughter laws, civil liability for abuse or neglect, misdemeanor criminal charges for neglect or injury of a child, and felony criminal charges for neglect or injury of a child. The other state is Virginia.

During Monday’s protest, about 100 people marched from Julia Davis Park to the Capitol with protest signs and small replica coffins. A U-Haul truck pulled up in front of the Capitol and unloaded dozens more. The marchers braved wind chills in the teens.

“One child’s death is too many — 183 is disgraceful,” Wingate said.

Protesters carried 183 symbolic child-sized coffins to the Idaho Capitol steps on Monday, calling for Idaho to repeal its faith-healing exemption. That law allows parents to deny their children medical care without civil or criminal liability, even if the children die.

He said several groups that have been involved in the issue decided not to participate in Monday’s march because of the use of the symbolic coffins, but organizers persisted. “We march to send a clear message to legislators that there are too many deaths,” he said. “One coffin says that message. One hundred and eighty-three screams that message.””

One comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s